Russell Tribunal on Palestine aims to hold the international community to account

Russell Tribunal on Palestine aims to hold the international community to account

by Frank Barat*

Today, 1 March 2010, the first session of the Russell Tribunal on Palestine (RTP) will be held in Barcelona. The RTP is a peoples’ tribunal focusing not on Israel’s obligations under international humanitarian law (IHL) such as the Fourth Geneva Convention, but on the obligations of the international community of signatory states which sustain and enable Israel’s continuous violations of international law. This date also coincides with the 6th International Israeli Apartheid Week.

Israel is continuously violating the principles of the 1949 Geneva Conventions that sought to ensure crimes against humanity would never happen again.
Israel has violated more than 60 UN resolutions and countless legal and diplomatic calls to abide by international law in relation to the expansion of illegal settlements, denial of the right of return and the continuing occupation of the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, the Gaza Strip and the Syrian Golan Heights. Dozens of reports, investigations and inquiries have produced evidence of alleged Israeli war crimes and crimes against humanity, including massacres, collective punishment, home demolitions and extrajudicial killings on a cyclical scale over the past 62 years.

In 2004, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) issued an advisory opinion finding Israel’s wall in the West Bank illegal and contrary to international law. The opinion was the key tenet of a 54-page document covering illegal settlements, the appropriation of natural resources and Israel’s violation of the Fourth Geneva Convention over the past 40 years, and reminded that IHL signatory states had an obligation "not to recognize the illegal situation resulting from the construction of the wall and not to render aid or assistance in maintaining the situation created by such construction" and "to ensure compliance by Israel with international humanitarian law as embodied in that Convention."

The ruling sparked hopes in the Palestinian community and international solidarity movements that finally, not only had Israeli violations been legally judged but that the responsibilities of the states which enable Israeli impunity to continue would be put to the test. Six years and 500 kilometers of wall on, the continued construction of the wall casts a shadow over international law.

Or does it?

The RTP is an independent initiative which intends to generate a public literacy in international law and the possibilities for the rule of law if respected to dismantle and disempower the reproduction of the occupation as a military, cultural and economic movement.

Israel is an international entity, kept afloat not just financially and politically by international state partners and supporters, but "legally" by the continued legitimization of illegal acts and "facts on the ground" by these states. Israel’s most important market is not economic or military — it is the market of legitimacy, the permission it receives to normalize crimes against humanity to its own citizens and the international community. This can only happen with the complicity of non-IHL compliant states. The RTP is a way of publicly pointing the finger at these states and mobilizing public opinion towards holding them accountable for the ongoing human rights violations in Palestine.

The RTP is composed of four sessions. The first in Barcelona from 1-3 March, focuses on establishing whether the European Union as an entity has fulfilled its obligations under international law. At the end of 2010, a London session will scrutinize the complicity of corporations in normalizing and perpetuating Israel’s violations of international law as well as labor rights in Palestine/Israel. In mid-2011, a session in South Africa will examine the applicability of the crime of apartheid in the context of Israel. The final session will be held in the United States in late 2011 and will analyze the role of the US within the United Nations and decision-making processes on issues of violating international law.

The RTP is not a talking shop. For too long Israel has been the focus of international campaigning as if it alone is responsible for the oppression of the Palestinian people, and as if it has been acting alone. The RTP is about making the links between the crimes committed on the ground in Palestine and their international sponsors. If we want to popularize the notion of "normalization" of the occupation as a key obstacle to a just peace, then understanding how this "normalization" operates on an international legal level in the corridors of Washington, Brussels and London, as well as Tel Aviv, is a vital part of challenging it.

As Israeli think tanks and lobby groups bemoan the rise of "delegitimization" of Israel on a popular level within Europe, the actual, pragmatic delegitimization of Israeli criminal policies is still unrealized and unimplemented by countries that have not just the means but the obligations to do this. The RTP contributes to the growing movement for boycott, divestment and sanctions by popularizing the facts behind the arguments for why states have a responsibility to implement sanctions against Israel, and for companies to withdraw from illegal projects and for the public to boycott Israeli institutions, goods and the normalization of apartheid.

The Geneva Conventions were created and agreed upon by the countries of the world in 1949, under popular pressure, as the legal means to ensure that crimes against humanity committed around the world during the Second World War would never happen again. The principles and tenets of these laws are being violated by Israel continuously. These laws stem from liberation struggles and sacrifices of movements in the past, and are on our side, the side of the people. We can use these laws as guides to build the conditions for genuine justice and universal human rights, and a world based on solidarity and equality.


A live streaming of the session can be viewed here:

Frank Barat
Coordinator of the Russell Tribunal on Palestine.

Rumsfeld hit with torture lawsuit while visiting Paris

Rumsfeld hit with torture lawsuit while visiting Paris
Jason Rhyne
Published: Friday October 26, 2007
Read more here
Former US Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld's jaunt to France was interrupted today by an unscheduled itinerary item -- he was slapped with a criminal complaint charging him with torture.

Rumsfeld, in Paris for a discussion sponsored by the magazine Foreign Policy, was tracked down by representatives of a coalition of international human rights groups, who informed the architect of the US invasion of Iraq that they had submitted a torture suit against him in French court.

The filed documents allege that during his tenure, the former defense secretary "ordered and authorized" torture of detainees at both the American-run Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq and the US military's detainment facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

The head of one of the groups responsible for bringing the charges, the US-based Center for Constitutional Rights, told RAW STORY today by phone that the suit was a long time coming.

"We've been working on cornering Rumsfeld and getting him indicted somewhere going on three years now," said the Center's president, Michael Ratner. "Four days ago, we got confidential information he was going to be in France."

Joined by activists, attorneys for the human rights groups caught up with Rumsfeld on his way to a breakfast meeting. "He was walking down the street with just one person," said Ratner.

"Around 20 campaigners gave Rumsfeld a rowdy welcome...yelling 'murderer,' waving a banner and trying to push into the building," reports AFP.

Ratner, who wasn't personally at the scene, says his sources told him that the former defense secretary made some pre-scheduled remarks at the meeting before ducking through a door leading to the US Embassy.

According to Ratner, France has a legal responsibility under international law to prosecute Rumsfeld for torture abuses.

"If a torturer comes into your territory," he said, "there's an obligation to either prosecute the person or return him to a place where he will be prosecuted."

The rights groups notably cite three memorandums signed by the defense secretary between October 2002 and April 2003 "legimitizing the use of torture" including the "hooding" of detainees, sleep deprivation and the use of dogs.

Although his group has been a part of previous attempts to bring charges against Rumsfeld, including two former tries in Germany, Ratner believes French court has the highest chance of success.

"There are Guantananamo detainees who were tortured that are living in France," he said. "It gives French courts another reason to prosecute."

Ratner says Europe is "getting very hot for Rumsfeld," and suggests a French court could at least issue its version of a subpoena.

"We hope that this case will move forward," he said, "especially as the US says it can continue to torture people."

Other groups involved in the complaint include the International Federation of Human Rights, the French League for Human Rights and Germany's European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights.

More details about the lawsuit are available at the website of the Center for Constitutional Rights.

Recent Articles


From Afghanistan to Iraq: Connecting the Dots With Oil
By Richard W. Behan, AlterNet
Monday 05 February 2007

Stand Up Against the Surge
by Molly Ivins, January 11, 2007

The Ludicrous Attacks on Jimmy Carter's Book
By NORMAN FINKELSTEIN, December 28, 2006

Starbucks Against Ethiopia
By Eric Leser, Le Monde, Thursday 14 December 2006

A Closing Call for Impeachment
by John Nichols,Published on Saturday, December 9, 2006 by The Nation

Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney Introduces Articles of Impeachment, Faces Vicious Attacks by Media
Submitted by davidswanson on Sat, 2006-12-09 12:09.

Mortality after the 2003 invasion of Iraq: a cross-sectional cluster sample survey
from The Lancet , 12 October 2006

Great piece of writing by Uri Avnery - Israel military

Alice in Nuclear Blunderland
March 8, 2006

The Case for Impeachment
Why we can no longer afford George W. Bush
Lewis H. Lapham - Harper's Magazine
February 27, 2006.

Iran and the Bomb
By Immanuel Wallerstein
Feburary 15, 2006

Defense or Aggression?


Apocalypse Soon
Robert S. McNamara
Foreign Policy - May/June 2005 Issue

A Revolution in American Nuclear Policy
Jonathan Schell
May 25, 2005

Proof the Fix Was In
Ray McGovern /
May 5, 2005

Matthew Rycroft memo on meeting with Blair on Iraq
23 July 2002

Myths and Reality


President Bush's Foreign Policy Discussion in the 2005 State of the Union Address
By Stephen Zunes - Foreign Policy in Focus
February 2005

What I Heard about Iraq
Eliot Weinberger
January 11, 2005

The Unwinnable War
James Carroll - the Boston Globe
September 7, 2004

Victory in the War on Terror
Gwynne Dyer
2 September, 2004

Not Scared Yet? Try Connecting These Dots
Ray McGovern - BuzzFlash
August 9, 2004

Fabricating Terror
William Rivers Pitt - t r u t h o u t
August 4, 2004

The Day The Constitution Died
Molly Ivins - Alternet
June 11, 2004

The War of the Words
Terry Jones
April 30, 2004

Britain and the US did everything to avoid a peaceful solution in Iraq and Afghanistan
George Monbiot
Tuesday, November 11, 2003
The Guardian

We report, you get it wrong
Jim Lobe
Asia Times
October 4th, 2003

Leçons sur la façon de mentir à propos de l'Irak, par Brian Eno ... en français
Brian Eno
the Observer
August 17, 2003

THE WAR ON TRUTH - John Pilger
John Pilger
July 31, 2003

Senator ROBERT BYRD: Road of Cover-Up is a Road to Ruin
Senator Robert Byrd
June 26, 2003

Rep. Waxman's Letter to Condoleeza Rice
June 10, 2003

Why America Is Waking UP

Marion McKeone
June 8, 2003

Hiroshima Anniversary - John Pilger
John Pilger
Aug 14, 2003

Lies, Lies, Lies
by Rumsfeld, Bush, Cheney, Fleischer, Powell..
before the war started

We Say No


The New Face of Protest?
by Karen Houppert
The Nation
March 28, 2005

Petition to the Canadian Government to give sanctuary to US war objectors
War Resisters Support Campaign

Canada Denies Refugee Status for Jeremy Hinzman
25 March 25, 2005

George Bush, When are you going to tell the truth to the people of the United States?
Kevin Benderman, Conscientious Objector

Deserters: We Won't Go to Iraq
Pentagon admits that more than 5,500 servicemen have deserted
December 8, 2004

"This war is about money"
Prison will become a more sane option than trying to take Fallujah for the fourth time.
A soldier in Iraq

Sgt. Camilo Mejia: First Iraqi War Veteran to Refuse Further Military Service
Citizen Soldier

Army Rejects C.O. Claim of Camilo Mejia, Wrongly Claiming that It's Based Soley on His Political Opposition to Iraq War
Citizen Soldier

The Iraqi Quagmire


Who's Better Off?
Representative Ron Paul (R-Tex.)
April 7th, 2005

Mother of Fallen Soldier Responds to Iraq Withdrawal Debate
Cindy Sheehan
March 11th, 2005

Getting the Purple Finger
by Naomi Klein - The Nation
February 10, 2005

No amount of spin can conceal Iraqis' hostility to US occupation
Sami Ramadani - The Guardian
February 01 2005
(The Vietnam turnout was good as well)

An Election to Anoint an Occupation
Had it been held in Zimbabwe, the west would have denounced it
Salim Lone - Guardian
January 31, 2005

Support Our Troops: Bring Them Home
by Howard Zinn - The Miami Herald
January 22, 2005

Fallujah, City without a Future?
Michael Schwartz -
January 14, 2005

A global gulag to hide the war on terror's dirty secrets
Bush is now thinking of building jails abroad to hold suspects for life
Jonathan Steele - The Guardian
January 14, 2005

Hold the elections, then get out.
Most of our partners in Iraq are preparing to leave. We should too
Robin Cook - The Guardian
January 14, 2005

This election could plunge Iraq further into the abyss.
Rigged polls held under foreign occupation have a notorious pedigree
Seumas Milne - The Guardian
January 13, 2005

Falluja: the Homecoming and the Homeless
Patrick Cockburn in Baghdad and Kim Sengupta
The Independent
December 11, 2004

In Iraq, the US does eliminate those who dare to count the dead
Naomi Klein - The Guardian
December 4, 2004

Iraq's Silent Dead
Jeffrey Sachs -
December 02, 2004

The graves of Falluja show the reality of Iraq's occupation
Rana Kabbani - The Guardian
November 23, 2004

Onslaught on Samarra escalates in "dress rehearsal" for major US assault on rebels
Kim Sengupta in Baghdad - The Independent
October 3, 2004

Things are worse in Iraq than the Bush Administration Tells the American People
A Wall Street Journal Reporter's E-Mail from Baghdad
Farnaz Fassihi
October 3, 2004

Far graver than Vietnam
Sidney Blumenthal - The Guardian
September 16, 2004

Despair in Iraq over the Forgotten Victims
Patrick Cockburn - The Independent
September 9, 2004

Naomi Klein - The Guardian
January 24, 2004

We are facing death in Iraq for no reason
Tim Predmore - The Guardian
September 19, 2003

the boys from Bravo Company
Bob Graham - London Evening Standard
June 19, 2003

Bush's Vietnam by John Pilger
John Pilger - The New Statesman
June 22, 2003

The right to resist
Seumas Milne - The Guardian
June 19, 2003

It's the Oil


Are we running out of oil?
Peak Oil FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

Secret US Plans for Iraq's Oil
By Greg Palast, reporting for BBC Newsnight
March 17, 2005

GlobalCorp - An Important Announcement
By Michael C. Ruppert - From The Wilderness
March 10, 2005

A Game As Old As Empire
By Amy Goodman, Democracy Now!
John Perkins, author of Confessions of an Economic Hit Man, reveals how the U.S. became the world's largest superpower: by forcing developing countries into debt.
December 31, 2004

Adventure Capitalism - The Hidden 2001 Plan to Carve-up Iraq
Greg Palast
October 27, 2004

Bush and Sharon - The Oil Connection
Conn Hallinan
May 26, 2004

Plan now for a world without oil
Michael Meacher
January 5, 2004

Operation Oil Immunity
Steve Kretzmann and Jim Vallette -
July 23, 2003

Bottom of the barrel

The world is running out of oil - so why do politicians refuse to talk about it?
George Monbiot - The Guardian
December 2, 2003

The Neocons Lay Their Plans


The Power of Nightmares
by Katrina vanden Heuvel - The Nation
January 26, 2005

The Peter Principle and the Neocon Coup
Robert Scheer - The Los Angeles Times
November 16, 2004

NAOMI KLEIN talks about the NeoCons
Globe and Mail
December 20, 2003

America's War for Global Domination
by Michel Chossudovsky
Centre for Research on Globalization
December 15, 2003

The Project for a New American Empire
Duane Shank
September-October 2003

NeoCons Ignored in the Media
Camille T. Taiara - San Francisco Bay Guardian
Sept 10, 2003

Paul Krugman on the Radical Right
NY Times
June 13, 2003

Pro Israel Hawks in Washington
Joel Beinin
April 6, 2003

Who's Profiting?


The Rise of Disaster Capitalism
Naomi Klein - The Nation
April 15, 2005

Fraud and corruption: Where has Iraq’s money gone?
The US occupation regime helped itself to $8.8 bn of mostly Iraqi money in just 14 months
George Monbiot - The Guardian
February 8, 2005

What Did Eisenhower Mean When He Warned of a Military Industrial Complex? Take a Look at the Carlyle Group.
June 23, 2003

Nation Builders for Hire
Dan Baum
The New York Times
June 22, 2003

The U.S. vs. Europe


Why France is America's True Friend
Eric Margolis
The Toronto Sun
March 9, 2003

Whether to Be Loved Or Feared
Mark Engler
July 3, 2003

War, Peace and International Law


Bush Fools Americans by Appearing to Accept McCain's Ban on Torture
by Evan Augustine Peterson, III - Dissident Voice
December 17, 2005

Basics of International Humanitarian Law as summarized by the ICRC

California NGOs sue US for Attacks on Hospitals in Falluja
Iraqi Democrats Against Occupation (IDAO)
December 12, 2004

CCR seeks Criminal Investigation in Germany of U.S. Officials for War Crimes in Abu Ghraib Torture
Center for Constitutional Rights
Howard Zinn - The Progressive.
November 11, 2004

Dissent at the War Memorial
There is no such thing as a 'good war'
Howard Zinn - The Progressive.
July 22, 2004

International Humanitarian Law
by Michele Ernsting, Radio Netherlands
June 16, 2004

The Crimes at Abu Ghraib Are Not the Worst
by Robert Higgs - CommonDreams
May 10, 2004

A Fig Leaf to Cover Occupation
Phyllis Bennis
October 16, 2003

Beware the Bluewash
George Monbiot - The Guardian
August 26, 2003

Le meilleur des mondes selon Washington
Noam Chomsky
August 2003
Le Monde Diplomatique

Hans Blix Interview
Helen Smith
The Guardian
June 16, 2003

Let Them Hate As Long As They Fear
Paul Krugman - NY Times
March 7, 2003

Empire and Exterminism
by David Watson
New Internationalist
May 2000

After Iraq - the Expanding Empire?


The Dangerous Implications of the Hariri Assassination and the U.S. Response
by Stephen Zunes -
February 19, 2005

Democratic Occupation
by Neve Gordon - In These Times
February 11th, 2005

Going Global: Building a Movement Against Empire
Phyllis Bennis
May 16-17

Inside the U.S.A


Bolton Nominated to Destroy UN
By Marjorie Cohn
t r u t h o u t
April 4, 2005

The Coming Wars
What the Pentagon can now do in secret.
by Seymour M. Hersh - New Yorker
January 17, 2005

Fireworks in Washington, despair around the world
The Bush administration is in denial about its disastrous failure in Iraq
Robin Cook - The Guardian
January 21, 2005

Long-Term Plan Sought For Terror Suspects
Dana Priest, Washington Post
January 2, 2005

Goodbye to 2004, another year of living stupidly
Peter Schrag - The Sacramento Bee
December 29, 2004

How We Became Barbarians
Getting in Touch with Your Inner Terrorist
Michael Neumann - CoutnerPunch
December 16, 2004

Smoking while Iraq burns
Kerry's true gift to Bush: not just the presidency, but impunity
Naomi Klein - The Guardian
November 26, 2004

How to End the Iraq War
Tom Hayden - AlterNet
November 23, 2004

Can You Name the Country?
Bill Douglas - Kansas City
October 2003

We Stand Our Ground
William Rivers Pitt
August 10, 2003

US Nobel Laureate Slams Bush Gov't as "Worst" in American History
Matthias Streitz - Der Spiegel
July 29, 2003

What's Happening in America?
Eliot Weinberger
June 1, 2003

Patriot Act II Destroys What Is Left of American Liberty
A Brief Analysis of the Domestic Security Enhancement Act 2003
Alex Jones -
February 10, 2003

Jimmy Carter and the world's haves and have-nots
Jim Wright (former speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives)
Star-Telegram, Fort Worth, Texas
October 2, 1999

U.S: November 2004 Elections


Time to end the voting blackout
Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney
January 6, 2005

Ten preliminary reasons why the Bush vote does not compute
and why Congress must investigate...
by Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld and Harvey Wasserman
January 3, 2005

20 Amazing Facts About Voting In The United States
by Bob Rowe
December, 2004

The Most Misleading Foreign Policy Statements Made by the Candidates in the Vice-Presidential Debate
by Stephen Zunes - CommonDreams
October 6, 2004

Mr Tall and Mr Small
by Greg Palast
September 30, 2004

Jimmy Carter Denounces Voter Fraud
Still Seeking a Fair Florida Vote
by Jimmy Carter
Washington Post
September 27, 2004

The Triumph of Anything Goes
by David Greenberg
Washington Monthly
September 4, 2004

The Bad or the Terrible
George Monbiot - The Guardian
August 17, 2004

September 11, 2001

SEPTEMBER 11, 2001

9/11: The Day the World Ended, Three Years On
John Chuckman - Interactivist Info Exchange
September 2, 2004

The 9/11 Report Misses the Point
Marjorie Cohn - t r u t h o u t
July 24, 2004

9/11 Widow's Bush Treason Suit Disappears From Media Reports
W. David Kubiak
December 5, 2003

Israel / Palestine


The end of a viable Palestinian state
Jeff Halper
Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions
27 March 2005

If it were the Reverse
Gideon Levy - Haaretz
July 18, 2004

Interview with Noam Chomsky
Junaid Alam and Noam Chomsky; Left Hook
ZNet, March 10, 2004

New Mideast Peace Bids - A Pocket Guide
Bradley Burston - Haaretz
December 10, 2003

Israel Trains U.S. Assasination Squads
Julian Borger - The Guardian
December 9, 2003

Extracts from the Ziegler report to the United Nations about the humanitarian situation in Palestine
November 2003

Rapport de Jean Ziegler aux Nations-Unies sur la situation humanitaire en Palestine
Novembre 2003

The Real Obstacle to Peace is Sharon, Not Arafat
Avi Shlaim - IHT
September 24, 2003

Israel A Danger
Charley Reese
September 24, 2003

The Swelling Cost of Israel to the U.S.
David R. Francis
The Christian Science Monitor



We Finally Got Our Frankenstein... and He Was In a Spider Hole
Michael Moore
December 14, 2003

The Speech We Didn't Hear - George W. Resigns
Greg Palast
September 11, 2003